SHESTI MAI ENGINEERING OOD AND OTHERS v. BULGARIA / ECHR

Notes

Date	20/09/2011
AppNr	17854/04
Body	Court (Fourth Section)
Type	Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)
Articles	34; 35; 35-1; 37; 37-1; 37-1-a; 41; P1-1; P1-1-1
Violated / NonViolated	P1-1

Conclusions:

Pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage - award
Preliminary objections joined to merits and dismissed (Victim, non-exhaustion of domestic remedies)
Struck out of the list
Violation of P1-1

Keywords:

(art. 34) victim
(art. 35-1) exhaustion of domestic remedies
(art. 37-1-c) continued examination not justified
(p1-1-1) interference
(p1-1-1) peaceful enjoyment of possessions
positive obligations

ECHR Notes

Originating Body	Court (Fourth Section)
Document Type	Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)
Language	ENGLISH
Application Number	17854/04
Importance Level	2
Represented by	MARGARITOVA-VUCHKOVA S. ; KIRILOV K.
Respondent State	Bulgaria
Date of Judgment	20/09/2011
Applicability	P1-1 applicable
Conclusion	Struck out of the list ; Preliminary objections joined to merits and dismissed (victim, non-exhaustion of domestic remedies) ; Violation of P1-1 ; Pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage - award
Articles	34 ; 35 ; 35-1 ; 37 ; 37-1 ; 37-1-a ; 41 ; P1-1 ; P1-1-1
Separate Opinions	No
Law at Issue	Sections 71 and 74 of the Commerce Act 1991
Strasbourg Case Law	Anheuser-Busch Inc. v. Portugal [GC], no. 73049/01, § 83, ECHR 2007-I ; Association and H. v. Austria, no. 9905/82, Commission decision of 15 March 1984, Decisions and Reports (DR) 36, p. 187 ; Belev and Others v. Bulgaria, nos. 16354/02, 16485/02, 16878/02, 16885/02, 16886/02, 16889/02, 17333/02, 17340/02, 17344/02, 17613/02, 17725/02, 17726/02, 18410/02, 18413/02, 18414/02, 18416/02, 21023/02, 21024/02, 21027/02, 21029/02, 21030/02, 21033/02, 21038/02, 21052/02, 21071/02, 21284/02, 21378/02, 21800/02, 22430/02, 22433/02, 26478/02, 26498/02, 31049/02, 31333/02, 31518/02, 37816/02, 42567/02, 43529/02, 758/03, 3461/03 and 11219/03, § 85, 2 April 2009 ; Bennich-Zalewski v. Poland, no. 59857/00, 22 April 2008 ; Bramelid and Malmström v. Sweden, nos. 8588/79 and 8589/79, Commission decision of 12 October 1982, DR 29, p. 64 ; Broniowski v. Poland [GC], no. 31443/96, ECHR 2004-V ; Brumarescu v. Romania (just satisfaction) [GC], no. 28342/95, § 20, ECHR 2000-I ; Brusco v. Italy (dec.), no. 69789/01, ECHR 2001-IX ; Capital Bank AD v. Bulgaria, no. 49429/99, § 134, 24 November 2005 ; Carson and Others v. the United Kingdom [GC], no. 42184/05, §§ 56 and 58, ECHR 2010-... ; Comingersoll S.A. v. Portugal [GC], no. 35382/97, ECHR 2000-IV ; Dacia SRL v. Moldova (just satisfaction), no. 3052/04, § 60-61, 24 February 2009 ; De Wilde, Ooms and Versyp v. Belgium (Article 50), 10 March 1972, § 20, Series A no. 14 ; Družstevní záložna Pria and Others v. the Czech Republic, no. 72034/01, § 89, 31 July 2008 ; Erdogan v. Turkey, no. 19807/92, Commission decision of 16 January 1996, DR 84-A, p. 5 ; Forminster Enterprises Limited v. the Czech Republic, no. 38238/04, 9 October 2008 ; Freitag v. Germany, no. 71440/01, § 51 and 54, 19 July 2007 ; Fuklev v. Ukraine, no. 71186/01, §§ 90-91, 7 June 2005 ; Guzzardi v. Italy, 6 November 1980, § 114, Series A no. 39 ; Hornsby v. Greece, 19 March 1997, § 37 in fine, Reports of Judgments and Decisions 1997-II ; Hutten-Czapska v. Poland [GC], no. 35014/97, § 163, ECHR 2006-VIII ; Iatridis v. Greece [GC], no. 31107/96, § 47, ECHR 1999-II ; Iatridis v. Greece (just satisfaction) [GC], no. 31107/96, § 32, ECHR 2000-XI ; Ivanov and Others v. Bulgaria, no. 46336/99, § 32, 24 November 2005 ; Kamburov v. Bulgaria (dec.), no. 14336/05, § 61 in fine, 6 January 2011 ; Kostic v. Serbia, no. 41760/04, § 66, 25 November 2008 ; Kuncheva v. Bulgaria, no. 9161/02, § 18, 3 July 2008 ; Kushoglu v. Bulgaria, no. 48191/99, § 49, 10 May 2007 ; Kushoglu v. Bulgaria (just satisfaction), no. 48191/99, 3 July 2008 ; Lisev v. Bulgaria, no. 30380/03, § 33, 26 February 2009 ; Marini v. Albania, no. 3738/02, 18 December 2007 ; Maznyak v. Ukraine, no. 27640/02, § 22, 31 January 2008 ; Melnik v. Ukraine, no. 72286/01, §§ 61-63, 28 March 2006 ; Mileva and Others v. Bulgaria, nos. 43449/02 and 21475/04, 25 November 2010 ; Miloševic v. the Netherlands (dec.), no. 77631/01, 19 March 2002 ; Nuray Sen v. Turkey (no. 2), no. 25354/94, §§ 199-200, 30 March 2004 ; Ogur v. Turkey [GC], no. 21594/93, § 67, ECHR 1999-III ; Olczak v. Poland (dec.), no. 30417/96, 7 November 2002 ; Özgür Gündem v. Turkey, no. 23144/93, §§ 34 and 36, ECHR 2000-III ; Patrikova v. Bulgaria, no. 71835/01, §§ 113 and 115, 4 March 2010 ; Plechanow v. Poland, no. 22279/04, §§ 99-100, 7 July 2009 ; Scordino v. Italy (no. 1) [GC], no. 36813/97, § 180, ECHR 2006-V ; Sedelmayer v. Germany (dec.), nos. 30190/06 and 30216/06, 10 November 2009 ; Sierpinski v. Poland, no. 38016/07, §§ 68-69, 3 November 2009 ; Sildedzis v. Poland, no. 45214/99, § 58, 24 May 2005 ; Sovtransavto Holding v. Ukraine, no. 48553/99, ECHR 2002-VII ; Sovtransavto Holding v. Ukraine (just satisfaction), no. 48553/99, 2 October 2003 ; Stec and Others v. the United Kingdom (dec.) [GC], nos. 65731/01 and 65900/01, § 32, ECHR 2005-X ; Stretch v. the United Kingdom, no. 44277/98, 24 June 2003 ; Todorova and Others v. Bulgaria (just satisfaction), nos. 48380/99, 51362/99, 60036/00 and 73465/01, 24 April 2008 ; Trippel v. Germany, no. 68103/01, § 18, 4 December 2003 ; Tsonyo Tsonev v. Bulgaria, no. 33726/03, § 24, 1 October 2009 ; Tunnel Report Limited v. France, no. 27940/07, § 37, 18 November 2010 ; Ukraine-Tyumen v. Ukraine, no. 22603/02, § 51, 22 November 2007 ; Van Oosterwijck v. Belgium, 6 November 1980, § 37, Series A no. 40 ; Wolkenberg and Others v. Poland (dec.), no. 50003/99, § 76, ECHR 2007-XIV (extracts) ; Yüksel Erdogan and Others v. Turkey, no. 57049/00, §§ 74-75, 15 February 2007 ; Zlínsat, spol. s r.o. v. Bulgaria, no. 57785/00, § 98, 15 June 2006 ; Zlínsat, spol. s r.o. v. Bulgaria (just satisfaction), no. 57785/00, § 43, 10 January 2008, with further references
Keywords	"(Art. 34) VICTIM" "(Art. 35-1) EXHAUSTION OF DOMESTIC REMEDIES" "(Art. 37-1-c) CONTINUED EXAMINATION NOT JUSTIFIED" "(P1-1-1) INTERFERENCE" "(P1-1-1) PEACEFUL ENJOYMENT OF POSSESSIONS" "POSITIVE OBLIGATIONS"

References 57

	1 KAMBUROV v. BULGARIA (II) Court (Fifth Section) Decision	06/01/2011
	5 MILEVA AND OTHERS v. BULGARIA 8 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	25/11/2010
	1 TUNNEL REPORT LIMITED v. FRANCE P1-1 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	18/11/2010
	2 PATRIKOVA v. BULGARIA 6 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	04/03/2010
	1 SEDELMAYER v. GERMANY Court (Fifth Section) Decision	10/11/2009
	3 SIERPINSKI v. POLAND P1-1, 6 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	03/11/2009
	5 TSONYO TSONEV v. BULGARIA 8, 13 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	01/10/2009
	11 PLECHANOW v. POLAND P1-1 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits)	07/07/2009
	1 BELEV AND OTHERS v. BULGARIA 6-1, P1-1 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	02/04/2009
	3 LISEV v. BULGARIA Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	26/02/2009
	3 DACIA S.R.L. v. MOLDOVA Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Just Satisfaction)	24/02/2009
	1 KOSTIC v. SERBIA P1-1 Court (Second Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	25/11/2008
	15 CARSON AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM P1-1, 14 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits)	04/11/2008
	2 FORMINSTER ENTERPRISES LIMITED v. THE CZECH REPUBLIC P1-1 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits)	09/10/2008
	5 DRUZSTEVNI ZALOZNA PRIA AND OTHERS v. THE CZECH REPUBLIC P1-1, 6-1 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits)	31/07/2008
	8 KUNCHEVA v. BULGARIA Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	03/07/2008
	1 KUSHOGLU v. BULGARIA Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Just Satisfaction)	03/07/2008
	1 TODOROVA AND OTHERS v. BULGARIA Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Just Satisfaction)	24/04/2008
	4 BENNICH-ZALEWSKI v. POLAND 6-1, P1-1 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	22/04/2008
	5 MAZNYAK v. UKRAINE Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	31/01/2008
	3 ZLINSAT, SPOL. S R.O. v. BULGARIA Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Just Satisfaction)	10/01/2008
	16 MARINI v. ALBANIA 6-1, 13, P1-1, 6-1 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	18/12/2007
	83 WOLKENBERG AND OTHERS v. POLAND Court (Fourth Section) Decision	04/12/2007
	5 UKRAINE-TYUMEN v. UKRAINE 6-1, P1-1 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits)	22/11/2007
	2 FREITAG v. GERMANY 6 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	19/07/2007
	5 KUSHOGLU v. BULGARIA Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	10/05/2007
	3 YÜKSEL ERDOGAN AND OTHERS v. TURKEY 2, 2 Court (Third Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	15/02/2007
	9 ZLINSAT, SPOL. S R.O. v. BULGARIA 6-1, P1-1 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	15/06/2006
	76 MELNIK v. UKRAINE 3, 13 Court (Second Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	28/03/2006
	27 CAPITAL BANK AD v. BULGARIA 6-1, P1-1 Court (First Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	24/11/2005
	5 IVANOV AND OTHERS v. BULGARIA 11, 13 Court (First Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	24/11/2005
	43 ANHEUSER-BUSCH INC. v. PORTUGAL P1-1 Court (Second Section) Judgment (Merits)	11/10/2005
	67 STEC AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM Court (Grand Chamber) Decision	06/07/2005
	43 FUKLEV v. UKRAINE 6-1, 13, P1-1 Court (Second Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	07/06/2005
	9 SILDEDZIS v. POLAND P1-1 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	24/05/2005
	58 HUTTEN-CZAPSKA v. POLAND P1-1 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	22/02/2005
	242 BRONIOWSKI v. POLAND P1-1 Court (Grand Chamber) Judgment (Merits)	22/06/2004
	26 NURAY SEN v. TURKEY (No. 2) 2, 13, 2, 3, 14 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	30/03/2004
	2 TRIPPEL v. GERMANY 6-1 Court (Third Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	04/12/2003
	24 STRETCH v. THE UNITED KINGDOM P1-1 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	24/06/2003
	298 SCORDINO and OTHERS (no. 1) v. ITALY Court (First Section) Decision	27/03/2003
	13 OLCZAK v. POLAND Court (Third Section) Decision (Final)	07/11/2002
	5 SOVTRANSAVTO HOLDING v. UKRAINE 6-1, P1-1 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	25/07/2002
	12 MILOSEVIC v. THE NETHERLANDS Court (Second Section) Decision	19/03/2002
	256 BRUSCO v. ITALY Court (Second Section) Decision	06/09/2001
	328 COMINGERSOLL S.A. v. PORTUGAL 6-1 Court (Grand Chamber) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	06/04/2000
	685 BRUMARESCU v. ROMANIA 6-1, P1-1 Court (Grand Chamber) Judgment (Merits)	28/10/1999
	188 OGUR v. TURKEY 2 Court (Grand Chamber) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	20/05/1999
	1086 IATRIDIS v. GREECE P1-1, 13 Court (Grand Chamber) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	25/03/1999
	471 HORNSBY v. GREECE 6-1 Court (Chamber) Judgment (Merits)	19/03/1997
	4 ERDOGAN, SiMSEK, HAKKI ILCI, ÖZKAYA, ELIUYGUN AND NURLU v. TURKEY Commission (Plenary) Decision	16/01/1996
	3 ERSÖZ, ÇETIN, KAYA AND ÜLKEM BASIN VE YAYINCILIK SANAYI TICARET LTD v. TURKEY Commission (Plenary) Decision	20/10/1995
	4 A. ASSOCIATION and H. v. AUSTRIA Commission (Plenary) Decision	15/03/1984
	28 BRAMELID and MALMSTRÖM v. SWEDEN Commission (Plenary) Decision	12/10/1982
	210 GUZZARDI v. ITALY 5-1, 3, 6, 9, 8 Court (Plenary) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	06/11/1980
	135 VAN OOSTERWIJCK v. BELGIUM Court (Plenary) Judgment (Preliminary Objections)	06/11/1980
	42 CASES OF DE WILDE, OOMS AND VERSYP ("VAGRANCY") v. BELGIUM (ARTICLE 50) Court (Plenary) Judgment (Just Satisfaction)	10/03/1972

Show all (57)

	1 TARNAWCZYK v. POLAND Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction) 35, 35-1, 41, P1-1, P1-1-1	07/12/2010
	9 OKCU v. TURKEY Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction) 6, 6-1, 13, 35, 35-1, 41, 46, 46-2, P1-1, P1-1-1	21/07/2009
	6 BIJELIC v. MONTENEGRO AND SERBIA Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction) 35, 35-3, 41, P1-1, P1-1-1	28/04/2009
	2 BAKALOV v. UKRAINE Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction) 6-1, 29-3, 34, 35-1, 41, P1-1	30/11/2004
	KHAMZAYEV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction) 2, 2-1, 8, 8-1, 8-2, 35, 35-1, 41, P1-1, P1-1-1	03/05/2011
	KERIMOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction) 2, 2-1, 8, 8-1, 35, 35-1, 41, P1-1, P1-1-1	03/05/2011
	7 SAGHINADZE AND OTHERS v. GEORGIA Judgment (Merits) 5, 5-3, 5-4, 8, 8-1, 8-2, 35, 35-1, 35-3, 41, P1-1, P1-1-1	27/05/2010
	11 PLECHANOW v. POLAND Judgment (Merits) 35, 35-1, 35-3, 41, P1-1, P1-1-1	07/07/2009
	LAKICEVIC AND OTHERS v. MONTENEGRO AND SERBIA Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction) 35, 35-1, 35-3, 41, P1-1, P1-1-1	13/12/2011
	VENTORINO v. ITALY Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction) 6, 6-1, 35, 35-1, 41, P1-1, P1-1-1	17/05/2011

ECHR CaseLaw

SHESTI MAI ENGINEERING OOD AND OTHERS v. BULGARIA View

Notes

ECHR Notes

References 57

Similar documents