ANATOLIY PONOMARYOV AND VITALIY PONOMARYOV v. BULGARIA / ECHR

Notes

Date	21/06/2011
AppNr	5335/05
Body	Court (Fourth Section)
Type	Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)
Articles	14; 14+P1-2; 41; P1-2
Violated / NonViolated	14P1-2
Citations	814

Conclusions:

Non-pecuniary damage - award
Pecuniary damage - claim dismissed
Violation of Art. 14
Violation of P1-2

Keywords:

(art. 14) discrimination
(art. 14) national origin
(art. 14) objective and reasonable justification
(p1-2) right to education

ECHR Notes

Originating Body	Court (Fourth Section)
Document Type	Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)
Language	ENGLISH
Application Number	5335/05
Importance Level	1
Represented by	STOYANOV V.S.
Respondent State	Bulgaria
Date of Judgment	21/06/2011
Applicability	Article 14 applicable ; P1-2 applicable
Conclusion	Violation of Art. 14 ; Violation of P1-2 ; Non-pecuniary damage - award ; Pecuniary damage - claim dismissed
Articles	14 ; 14+P1-2 ; 41 ; P1-2
Separate Opinions	No
Law at Issue	Section 4(3) of the 1991 National Education Act
Strasbourg Case Law	15 Foreign Students v. the United Kingdom, nos. 7671/76 and fourteen others, Commission decision of 19 May 1977, Decisions and Reports 9, p. 185 ; Abdulaziz, Cabales and Balkandali v. the United Kingdom, 28 May 1985, § 82, Series A no. 94 ; Anakomba Yula v. Belgium, no. 45413/07, § 38, ECHR 2009-... (extracts) ; Andrejeva v. Latvia [GC], no. 55707/00, ECHR 2009-... ; Budina v. Russia (dec.), no. 45603/05, ECHR 2009-... ; Burden v. the United Kingdom [GC], no. 13378/05, § 60 in fine, ECHR 2008-... ; C. v. Belgium, 7 August 1996, § 38, Reports 1996-III ; Campbell and Cosans v. the United Kingdom, 25 February 1982, § 41, Series A no. 48 ; Carson and Others v. the United Kingdom [GC], no. 42184/05, ECHR 2010-... ; Case “relating to certain aspects of the laws on the use of languages in education in Belgium” v. Belgium (merits), 23 July 1968, pp. 33-34, Series A no. 6 ; Çiftçi v. Turkey (dec.), no. 71860/01, ECHR 2004-VI ; Clift v. the United Kingdom, no. 7205/07, § 73, 13 July 2010 ; D.H. and Others v. the Czech Republic [GC], no. 57325/00, ECHR 2007-... ; Dabhi v. the United Kingdom, no. 28627/95, Commission decision of 17 January 1997, unreported ; Darby v. Sweden, 23 October 1990, § 28, Series A no. 187 ; E.B. v. France [GC], no. 43546/02, § 48, ECHR 2008-... ; Etxeberria and Others v. Spain, nos. 35579/03, 35613/03, 35626/03 and 35634/03, § 81, 30 June 2009 ; Fawsie v. Greece, no. 40080/07, 28 October 2010 ; Gaygusuz v. Austria, 16 September 1996, § 42, Reports of Judgments and Decisions 1996-IV ; Irfan Temel and Others v. Turkey, no. 36458/02, § 39, ECHR 2009-... ; J.M. v. the United Kingdom, no. 37060/06, 28 September 2010 ; Kafkaris v. Cyprus [GC], no. 21906/04, § 161 in limine, ECHR 2008-... ; Kjeldsen, Busk Madsen and Pedersen v. Denmark, 7 December 1976, § 52, Series A no. 23 ; Konrad and Others v. Germany (dec.), no. 35504/03, ECHR 2006-XIII ; Koua Poirrez v. France, no. 40892/98, § 46, ECHR 2003-X ; Leyla Sahin v. Turkey [GC], no. 44774/98, ECHR 2005-XI ; Luczak v. Poland, no. 77782/01, § 48, ECHR 2007-XIII ; McCann and Others v. the United Kingdom, 27 September 1995, § 153, Series A no. 324 ; Moustaquim v. Belgium, 18 February 1991, § 49 in fine, Series A no. 193 ; Mürsel Eren v. Turkey, no. 60856/00, ECHR 2006-II ; Niedzwiecki v. Germany, no. 58453/00, 25 October 2005 ; Okpisz v. Germany, no. 59140/00, 25 October 2005 ; Oršuš and Others v. Croatia [GC], no. 15766/03, ECHR 2010-... ; Pentiacova and Others v. Moldova (dec.), no. 14462/03, ECHR 2005-I ; Pham Hoang v. France, 25 September 1992, § 33, Series A no. 243 ; Pla and Puncernau v. Andorra, no. 69498/01, ECHR 2004-VIII ; Rasmussen v. Denmark, 28 November 1984, Series A no. 87 ; Romanenko and Others v. Russia, no. 11751/03, § 39, 8 October 2009 ; Runkee and White v. the United Kingdom, nos. 42949/98 and 53134/99, § 36, 10 May 2007 ; Saidoun v. Greece, no. 40083/07, 28 October 2010 ; Sejdic and Finci v. Bosnia and Herzegovina [GC], nos. 27996/06 and 34836/06, § 39, 22 December 2009 ; Sommerfeld v. Germany [GC], no. 31871/96, § 86, ECHR 2003-VIII ; Sorabjee v. the United Kingdom, no. 23938/94, Commission decision of 23 October 1995, unreported ; Stec and Others v. the United Kingdom (dec.) [GC], nos. 65731/01 and 65900/01, ECHR 2005-X ; Steel and Morris v. the United Kingdom, no. 68416/01, § 105, ECHR 2005-II ; Ünal Tekeli v. Turkey, no. 29865/96, § 51 in limine, ECHR 2004-X (extracts) ; Vikulov and Others v. Latvia (dec.), no. 16870/03, 25 March 2004 ; Weller v. Hungary, no. 44399/05, § 36, 31 March 2009 ; Wettstein v. Switzerland, no. 33958/96, § 41, ECHR 2000-XII ; Zarb Adami v. Malta, no. 17209/02, § 73, ECHR 2006-VIII ; Zeïbek v. Greece, no. 46368/06, 9 July 2009 ; Zubczewski v. Sweden (dec.), no. 16149/08, 12 January 2010
External Sources	Article 28 § 1 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child ; International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
Keywords	"(Art. 14) DISCRIMINATION" "(Art. 14) NATIONAL ORIGIN" "(Art. 14) OBJECTIVE AND REASONABLE JUSTIFICATION" "(P1-2) RIGHT TO EDUCATION"

Application Documents 2

	PONOMARYOV & OTHERS v. BULGARIA Court (Fifth Section) Decision (Final)	10/02/2009
	1 PONOMARYOV AND OTHERS v. BULGARIA Court (Fifth Section) Decision (Partial)	18/09/2007

References 49

	1 SAIDOUN v. GREECE 8, 14 Court (First Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	28/10/2010
	1 FAWSIE v. GREECE 8, 14 Court (First Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	28/10/2010
	2 J.M. v. THE UNITED KINGDOM 14, P1-1 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	28/09/2010
	5 CLIFT v. THE UNITED KINGDOM 14, 5 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	13/07/2010
	1 ZUBCZEWSKI v. SWEDEN Court (Third Section) Decision	12/01/2010
	14 SEJDIC AND FINCI v. BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA 14, P1-3, P12-1 Court (Grand Chamber) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	22/12/2009
	4 ROMANENKO AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA 10 Court (First Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	08/10/2009
	3 ZEIBEK v. GREECE P1-1, 14 Court (First Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	09/07/2009
	6 ETXEBERRIA BARRENA ARZA NAFARROAKO AUTODETERMINAZIO BILGUNEA AND AIARAKO AND OTHERS v. SPAIN P1-3, 10, 13 Court (Fifth Section) Judgment (Merits)	30/06/2009
	5 WELLER v. HUNGARY 8, 14 Court (Second Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	31/03/2009
	3 ANAKOMBA YULA v. BELGIUM 14, 6-1 Court (Second Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	10/03/2009
	1 IRFAN TEMEL AND OTHERS v. TURKEY P1-2 Court (Second Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	03/03/2009
	17 ANDREJEVA v. LATVIA 14, P1-1, 6-1 Court (Grand Chamber) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	18/02/2009
	15 CARSON AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM P1-1, 14 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits)	04/11/2008
	7 ORSUS AND OTHERS v. CROATIA 6-1, P1-2, 14 Court (First Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	17/07/2008
	1 BUDINA v. RUSSIA Court (First Section) Decision (Partial)	12/02/2008
	29 E.B. v. FRANCE 8, 14 Court (Grand Chamber) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	22/01/2008
	4 LUCZAK v. POLAND Court (Fourth Section) Decision	27/03/2007
	47 BURDEN AND BURDEN v. THE UNITED KINGDOM P1-1, 14 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	12/12/2006
	3 KONRAD AND OTHERS v. GERMANY Court (Fifth Section) Decision	11/09/2006
	47 STEC AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM P1-1, 14 Court (Grand Chamber) Judgment (Merits)	12/04/2006
	48 KAFKARIS v. CYPRUS Court (First Section) Decision	11/04/2006
	49 D.H. AND OTHERS v. THE CZECH REPUBLIC 14, P1-2 Court (Second Section) Judgment (Merits)	07/02/2006
	5 NIEDZWIECKI v. GERMANY 8, 14 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	25/10/2005
	10 OKPISZ v. GERMANY 8, 14 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	25/10/2005
	67 STEC AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM Court (Grand Chamber) Decision	06/07/2005
	25 ZARB ADAMI v. MALTA Court (Fourth Section) Decision	24/05/2005
	12 PENTIACOVA AND 48 OTHERS v. MOLDOVA Court (Fourth Section) Decision	04/01/2005
	32 UNAL TEKELI v. TURKEY 8, 14 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	16/11/2004
	18 PLA AND PUNCERNAU v. ANDORRA 8, 14 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	13/07/2004
	3 LEYLA SAHIN v. TURKEY 9 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits)	29/06/2004
	6 CIFTCI V. TURKEY Court (Third Section) Decision	17/06/2004
	8 VIKULOV et AUTRES contre la LETTONIE Court (First Section) Decision (Partial)	25/03/2004
	19 KOUA POIRREZ v. FRANCE 14, P1-1, 6-1 Court (Second Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	30/09/2003
	76 STEEL and MORRIS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM Court (Fourth Section) Decision (Partial)	22/10/2002
	5 EREN v. TURKEY Court (Third Section) Decision	06/06/2002
	17 NITECKI v. POLAND Court (First Section) Decision	21/03/2002
	10 SOMMERFELD v. GERMANY 8, 14, 6-1 Court (Fourth Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	11/10/2001
	74 WETTSTEIN v. SWITZERLAND 6-1 Court (Second Section) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	21/12/2000
	2 DABHI v. THE UNITED KINGDOM Commission (First Chambe… Decision	17/01/1997
	116 GAYGUSUZ v. AUSTRIA 14, P1-1 Court (Chamber) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	16/09/1996
	42 C. v. BELGIUM 8, 14 Court (Chamber) Judgment (Merits)	07/08/1996
	11 SORABJEE v. the UNITED KINGDOM Commission (Plenary) Decision	23/10/1995
	36 PHAM HOANG v. FRANCE 6-3-c, 6-1, 6-2 Court (Chamber) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	25/09/1992
	125 MOUSTAQUIM v. BELGIUM 8, 14, 8 Court (Chamber) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	18/02/1991
	42 DARBY v. SWEDEN 14, P1-1 Court (Chamber) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	23/10/1990
	264 ABDULAZIZ, CABALES AND BALKANDALI v. THE UNITED KINGDOM 8, 14, 13 Court (Plenary) Judgment (Merits and Just Satisfaction)	28/05/1985
	90 RASMUSSEN v. DENMARK 6, 14, 8 Court (Chamber) Judgment (Merits)	28/11/1984
	87 CAMPBELL AND COSANS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM P1-2, 3 Court (Chamber) Judgment (Merits)	25/02/1982

Show all (49)

ECHR CaseLaw

ANATOLIY PONOMARYOV AND VITALIY PONOMARYOV v. BULGARIA View

Notes

ECHR Notes

Application Documents 2

References 49

Citations Breakdown

Citations 1

Similar documents